There are a lot of downsides to "Sign in with Google", but I am generally willing to accept them because I think I could recover my account if I lost my password. I'm not certain I could do so, because we've all read plenty of horror stories about Google's customer support. But I don't think I could recover an Ethereum private key. I'm sure there are esoteric ways of doing this. But ultimately what I want is the comfort that if worst comes to worst, there is a human somewhere on the planet who can reset my password for me. They might be hidden in a nigh-impenetrable labyrinth of automated emails, but they exist, and I could get them to help me if I make enough of a fuss on Twitter.