Or consider health insurance. Do we really want young people paying the same premiums as 80 year olds?
Perhaps you think there's a negative societal byproduct of making a certain group of people feel marginalized/targeted. Does wanting to reduce this justify clear resource wastage, such as in the airport security example above?
Similarly, 80 year olds and especially people with pre-existing conditions, they did nothing wrong, so it's not fair to make them pay more.
Possible solutions are 1) monitor the suspicious individuals without inconveniencing them (e.g. monitor the 21-year old via a security camera), 2) distribute the inconvenience when possible (e.g. raise everyone's premiums a small amount for those who are more likely to be sick), or 3) offer some sort of compensation to people who have to be targeted.
Granting the security theater, If your searches aren't random you introduce a trivial way to bypass the searches. A bad actor simply has to con the contraband onto an unsuspecting low-risk passenger to convert his chances to a much higher success rate.
wrt health insurance, we should properly note that health insurance doesn't exist. It is not insurance but some kind of health care subscription. I am of course speaking as US citizen. A more useful analogy might be life insurance.
The negative societal byproduct of marginalizing certain groups is clearly not justified, it is the resource wastage.
"A bad actor simply has to con the contraband onto an unsuspecting low-risk passenger"
While it's true that this will happen, this isn't a valid argument for exactly equal search frequency across demographics.Lone wolf attacks are almost exclusively young or middle aged men. That isn't changing in response to venue or airport search policy.
Young people might be easier to convert into drug smugglers due to financial need, higher risk appetite, less family responsibilities and a higher chance of having gang affiliations. Even if smugglers recruit more old people in response to a skew towards searching young people more frequently, such a policy may still maximize the number of successful searches.
It is if your goal is to intercept contraband. Previous contraband seizure statistics will be skewed by survivor bias. Currently, in airports, everybody and every bag passes through an x-ray or metal detector. Airport or venue search policy is unable to affect demographics.
This kind of reasoning results in a spiral of paranoia and ineffective solutions (security theater) which is much worse than a waste of time and resources. This collective suspicion breeds the kind of resentment and distrust which I would argue contribute to the very problems they are purported to solve.
It isn't.
Some airports select a small subset of people and swab their bag manually for drug residue. If people are sampled randomly for swabbing, yet drug smugglers have a demographic skew to e.g. young people, then you've got a suboptimal policy in terms of maximizing the proportion of all searches that find illicit drugs.
> Previous contraband seizure statistics will be skewed by survivor bias.
What do you mean by this? Are you suggesting that it's difficult to design an appropriate skew in search frequencies due to a lack of high quality data about the demographics of drug smugglers?
> This kind of reasoning results in ... ineffective solutions (security theater)
I disagree. Peak ineffectiveness and theater is searching 90 year-old women as often as 21 year-old men, when nearly 100% of suicide attacks and mass shootings are perpetrated by young men and 0% by old women.
Searching 21 year-old men may still be theater to an extent, but it is less theatrical than searching 90 year-old women with equal frequency.
Aside from the trivial bypass you would introduce, that will additionally cause the survivor bias in your search statistics.
Adjusting some proportion of searches to one group or another in this way will ignore the types of people in the group. What works from NYC->Las Vegas will be absurd according to your logic when applied to NYC->Florida retirement communities. It is drugs or bombs? The results will also look different in both scenarios. The correct solution is screening.
I have news for you about drug smuggling, its the 21 year old who are caught. You should probably just let them have their MDMA.
It is all destined to be absurd, however; in the movie theater hypothetical, searching some percentage of 21 year old men is uselessly ineffective. What is the ratio of movie theater attendees to movie theater shooters? It's on the order of homeopathy. The logic and methodology in this is so tragically flawed.
> This kind of reasoning results in ... ineffective solutions (security theater)
You missed the important parts.
> Does wanting to reduce this justify clear resource wastage, such as in the airport security example above?
Hold on, your argument can't put aside the "security theatre aspect" while also using it as justification for policies. If it really is theatre, this wouldn't be doing anything more effectively except getting more people invested in the show going on.
Recall the Pan Am flight exploded over Scotland. Explosives were concealed in a radio.
Who is to say that grandma isn’t packing such a device?
The threat of a 9/11 style hijacking is largely neutralizes by reinforced cockpit doors. But any person can be a mule, knowingly or unknowingly, for contraband of various types.
Terrorist organizations aren't stupid, and they have members of all ages. If we made it our policy not to search 90-year-olds anymore, then they'd suddenly end up committing most of the attacks on flights.
> Or consider health insurance. Do we really want young people paying the same premiums as 80 year olds?
In this example, what are you saying that the 80-year-olds have control over?
"If we made it our policy not to search 90-year-olds anymore"
Even if that isn't the optimal policy (and I didn't suggest that it was) due to its exploitability, it doesn't then follow that having the same search probability for 90 year old women and 21 year old men is optimal.Perhaps searching young men with a 3x higher probability compared to old women is optimal.
What we can say with confidence, when considering only the immediate objective of flight safety (or venue security), is that an exactly equal search probability is definitely not optimal, due to nearly all instances of lone shooters and so on being young or middle aged men.
And skewed statistics accordingly, so that it would include them again. That’s how it already works, but on an intuition of particular security workers and/or general guidelines they receive.
They really wouldn’t. There aren’t that many 90 year olds available and it’s pretty hard to recruit them into terrorism (relative to 21 year olds).
Health insurance is a perfect example of intentionally restricting factors that may be considered to make a more fair system. Forget age. Most systems don't require a sick person to pay more than a healthy person even if the sick person is nearly guaranteed to take out more than they contribute.
> Perhaps you think there's a negative societal byproduct of making a certain group of people feel marginalized/targeted. Does wanting to reduce this justify clear resource wastage, such as in the airport security example above?
The extra security is the resource wastage. The flip side of "we can do less for this group" is "we can do more for that group".
Also, your comment here heavily implies you think that resource waste is obviously more important that making large groups of people feel marginalized. To be frank, even from the most sociopathic economic lens, I do think that exhibiting behaviors that perpetuate racist/religious/political/ageist/sexist/sexual orientation biased ideas have significantly higher negative externality costs to society. Especially those that implicitly convey that an outsider group is dangerous.
Back in our world: I don't believe in demonizing technologies because of what people might do with them. Facial recognition works, at least for identification of individuals. I cannot get on board with mandating denial of this fact for the sake of fear of bad policy based on this fact. It never, ever, under any circumstances whatsoever acceptable to ban people noticing true facts about how the world works.
What about demonizing technologies because of what people do with them, all the time, in positions of power?
> Facial recognition works, at least for identification of individuals. I cannot get on board with mandating denial of this fact for the sake of fear of bad policy based on this fact.
That's not really what this article is about, the article is just poorly titled.
> It never, ever, under any circumstances whatsoever acceptable to ban people noticing true facts about how the world works.
That's fine. In this case you should have no issue that I've noticed people who say stuff like this tend to harbor supremacist ideals.