The feedback on this redesign should serve as a reminder for startups: Ignore all feedback after a redesign and look at your metrics. Your metrics will tell you the real story whereas feedback will almost always be negative.
Ok so the new design is much faster. Great, that's awesome. But I feel completely disgusted by this. Default html colours with arial font-face would be better than this.
It's not a good idea to myopically focus on anything. Including data.