Crime has been down from the 1990s to 2020. People has been more and more scare of less and less crime.
> "defund the police" led Minneapolis to actually start working towards dismantling its police department
That is not the case, reading your link they are creating a "Department of Public Safety in Minneapolis to oversee policing, violence prevention, and community safety programs". So, from your link, nobody is dismantling the police department but they are changing its responsibilities and structure to be more effective with the current challenges.
> some extremists literally want to do that in New York
"extremists"
> need to see a policy framework worked out in smaller cities before they can be applied to New York
That is reasonable. Even better is to apply it to New York but in small scale. A little town and New York have little in common.