Let's say you get a hypothetical procedure. Insurance has already agreed to pay in-network providers between $1-3K for this procedure. But you got this procedure out-of-network. Why is insurance's liability suddenly $0 instead of whatever the lowest in-network fee schedule would be ($1K in this example)?
See I can understand insurance not wanting to foot substantially higher bills than in-network providers charge, but I cannot understand why it drops to $0 reimbursed when you leave network. It seems like an immoral "gotcha."
But then again I'd like to see insurance discounts/agreements banned. Make everything and nothing in-network and also normalize the insured/uninsured prices. No more "$100 for a band-aid, -$99 discount" shenanigans.
Obviously single-payer would be better yet still, but if we must keep using this broken private employer-linked insurer system let us at least keep band-aid fixing it until we can get enough political support to scrap it.