And if I run a guest wifi in one of the many countries where I have legal obligations to take steps to block illegal traffic because I am ultimately responsible for the emissions of my network, what would you suggest I do?
> DNS doesn't have a rich error vocabulary. For your ad-blocked domains, a traditional DNS server has to either lie (bogus answer) or claim no answer exists (NXDOMAIN or OK 0 answers) but HTTP has a rich variety of error codes.
It's a good thing that DNS has a limited vocabulary of error codes. I want the garbage website to think it couldn't load the ad because of a mysterious DNS issue. Having a reason like "DNSHTTP 486: Blocked by Client" would just make it that much easier for the site to deny you access/track you/detect your blocking activity.