It specifically says that the natural right will not be violated, how is that a legal right?
The BoR is, by plain definition, a codification of rights. To codify means to make into law, which is what it is: a law, implementing the formal recognition rights... and it does so by making illegal specific abuses.
It's supposed to be a way of showing that the government is subservient to the citizens, as it does not have the power to grant citizens rights. I doubt it's effective though, as most people seem to think the Constitution grants rights.
Maybe that's just me, but that's way too abstract for me. Have planets and stars always had certain rights purely by existing as well?
> and society chooses which ones should be protected
Well in that case you could make the case that every single person has every single right anyone could possibly have and the society chooses a subset of these rights as actual laws. I guess this is a way to eat your cake and have it, too, since it makes the difference between my and your view unobservable.
You are right that people have rights without the constitution. Other people are right that the constitution grants rights. The confusion is that you are both talking about different types of rights.
A law that says "the government can't legally do [x] to me", by definition, creates a legal right that I have "a right not to have the government do [x] to me". They are semantically different in perspective, but causal in relationship.
If people said "the constitution grants the right for our free speech not to be infringed" I'd probably ignore it. That's not how any discussion goes though.
Here's why I think this matters in this instance. By saying the 4th is "just a legal right," you are saying that the Constitution only grants it to certain people and the government can spy on anyone else. But by saying it's only a limitation, there's no qualifier on whose rights they can infringe.
Of course, international rights also need international enforcement, since a right without enforcement is just a nice thought. Perhaps we'll also have a world order to enforce these rights.
Expressing discontent with the status quo is one prong of consensus gathering.
Universal human rights have exploded to be adopted by much of the world, without an international government.
Rights are not just nice thoughts. Even oppressive governments don't have the resources to control everything everyone does (of course). Just adopting the outlook, just believing you are free will make you free to a great extent.
It's difficult to make the case that only citizens deserve rights without sliding into questionable ideologies.
If you're the US government, and you're justifying your power by saying that you respect human rights, and then you do a bait-and-switch and provide citizen's rights but not human rights, you just lied.
That being said, strictly speaking I disagree, citizens do not have full authority on rights and neither are all rights conferred to classes of citizens.