> The police department does, so they should be liable for those decisions.
Does it? Perhaps if they are using a bespoke solution, but they could just as easily be using a standard system procured at the county or state level.
> the entire department should have been informed to not trust the results until the underlying issue was found and fixed.
This doesn’t seem like a real world solution. Without knowing the frequency and nature of the problem this could be a massive overreaction.