I feel like the author doesn't understand the point of games...
Sorry! Your villagers all died by a plague. Game over!
Sorry! Your villagers all died by a plague. Game over!
The thing about games is that when everyone dies, you just click the "New Game" button and try again. Failing over-and-over again in a game is allowed. In fact, I dare say that modern games don't provide enough room for failure compared to older games.
I'd say the author understands perfectly well. It's still interesting to discuss where they deviate from reality and to what extent.