I think that this kind of drill helps a lot for cases where you can take a pre-planned route, like deploying that backup server or rerouting traffic. But the obvious question then is: Why not automate that as well?
When it comes to diagnosis or, worse, triage, in my experience you want independent free agents looking at the system all at once. You don't want a warroom-like atmosphere with a single screen but rather n+1 hackers focusing on what their first intuition tells them is the root cause. In a second step you want these hackers to convene and discuss their root cause hypotheses. If necessary, you want them to run experiemnts to confirm these hypotheses. And then you decide the appropriate reaction.