Throwing out the baby with the bathwater, because the bathwater (after careful searching) was found to have some impurity, is itself a tactic for pushing an agenda, not a fair and rational response. You can't just say "added eplanit => all bad, no trust", you have to show a pattern and intent, neither of which you have even attempted to do.
Is eplanit a disaster-capitalist or racist? That's usually what triggers it...
Which of those are Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Maajid Nawaz?
According to the SPLC, their addition was a mistake, and the retraction seems honest and reasonable. [0]
Now, me, I like my organizations to never admit-- uh, I mean make mistakes.
They made a list of 'Anti-Muslim extremists' and included both a victim of extremism and a former islamic extremist on it. Because their views which are informed by first hand experience are different from those held by the SPLC. Their entry on Nawaz also seemed to imply he was not a true muslim because he went to a strip club as well.
They settled a defamation lawsuit. The settlement terms included an apology and payment of $3 million.
If it was an honest mistake, how did it get to the point of having to settle for $3 million?