I think we, as the intellectual "elites", need to accept the following ugly reality:
1) A huge portion of the human population is highly susceptible to propaganda.
2) Exposing them to nuanced reality doesn't help them. In fact, anything complicated turns them off. They want simple truths.
3) This subpopulation is never going to change, and they're always going to be with us.
Given this reality, the only realistic option to protect our interests, aside from totalitarianism, is to feed this subpopulation counter-propaganda. To provide an alternative, easy-to-digest narrative that's aligned with humanism / Enlightenment values, but that is extremely dumbed down: The Voltaire Factor for the Hopelessly Credulous. The irony here isn't lost on me, but I see no gentle alternative.