They basically tried to license it to the other saw companies.
The other companies said hell no. We have the market.
So sawstop started building their own (great) saws. They really are pretty to very high quality. The saw stop feature is also very effective.
It's so effective that if you are running a woodworking shop in a school, or ever want to let your kids use your saw, or have staff using your saw, you really owe it to them to ALWAYS buy a sawstop.
I've worked with a few owners who took the approach you did. Inevitably someone loses a finger - and after the dust settles and folks ask why they didn't put this VERY simple and not that expense solution in place - they usually regret it. Either they feel guilty for chisling on some $ and having someone lose function in their hand or if they are here in CA they pay out BIG TIME for their stupidity.
The license fee was going to be around 3% of wholesale (so about $3 on a $100 wholesale saw that goes for $200 retail). I think he came very close to licensing to ryobi?
Anyways, if you think $3 for potentially incredibly QOL saving tech is too much for an inventor that actually invented something (and tested on his own finger) then I don't know what to tell you.
That said, once someone's parents (if you run a woodshop in a school) or employee sues you - you may start valuing this invention a bit more.
You can send in your activated cartridge to sawstop - if it was skin activated then they may replace it for free.
If you are concerned about a trip you can touch blade to piece with saw off and it'll tell you if would have tripped. Or do a first cut with system off. Or if you have a wet piece turn it off.
That said if you have a nail or something in piece there are situations that could trip it for sure.
It's no surprise that sawstop can make a nice saw for 4 to 17x the price of competitors.
If some safety feature is judged too important not to have, as it is common in cars, the government steps in and makes it mandatory, but it doesn't mean there are no more licensing fees. At best, the licensing fees are limited to a fair price.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/douglasbell/2019/08/13/60-years...
Sometimes companies and individuals think that it's wroth losing financially for the sake of wider safety.
There's a difference between the cost to provide something and the license fee. Note the Moderna licensed its covid patents for $0.
> a fair price
What's a fair price? What is the rule that says one party is greedy and the other is reasonable?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_and_non-discriminat...
Almost always those 0 cost licensing agreements are just PR stunts.
> On the other hand (!), maybe the onus for the lost fingers is on SawStop for demanding those licensing fees.
Also Walter:
> What's a fair price? What is the rule that says one party is greedy and the other is reasonable?
Are you seriously suggesting that they should just work for free?
The poster wanted to punish inventors for inventing. If that isn't a perverse incentive I don't know what is.
Please try reading what I wrote again.
Done.
Do you disagree that your writing says "the onus for lost finger is on SawStop"? Your writing seems very clear to me. I do not know why you are confused.
The other manufacturers would have had to immediately stop selling and possible have pulled all the other saws off the market. For liability reasons, you can't sell a line of saws that chop off fingers next to a line that doesn't. You're basically admitting the former is defective.
Or maybe you're right and we'll see an "admission of defect" suit sometime soon.
I'd think the opposite is true - you can't sell a $250 saw that won't cut someone's finger off next to a $200 saw and expect it to sell. No one thinks it'll happen to them... otherwise Saw-stop's own line of saws would dominate the market. Some people will pay the premium, but I'd bet that most will not.
Saw Y doesn't have safety features and you use it at your own risk of injury. Saw X will stop cutting the moment it detects a body part. You also use it at your own risk of injury.
I thought the issue with SawStop wasn't that the licensing was bad but that nobody was willing to take on the liability.
ie. If someone cut off their hand with a table saw, it was settled law that it was their own fault. If someone cut off their hand and the SawStop didn't fire, the manufacturer now had a gigantic liability.
Bosch came out with a superior design that doesn't use a brake at all, but were barred from selling it in the US because it infringed SawStop's patents.
Sawstop dropped blade below table. Bosch also dropped blade below table. So the invention was very fast acting sensing and then dropping blade. Sawstop added brake.
Sawstop ALSO did a brake. The brake made a pretty reasonable difference in terms of damage.
Plenty of youtube videos exposing this saw.
"SawStop uses a different mechanism to drop the blade, but also employs an aluminum brake. In our testing on both top and front strikes, the blade stopped with less damage to my hand than Bosch’s Reaxx."
The design was not superior and the infringement was not based on a brake or lack of one. The infringement was because of copy of the skin contact sensing / blade drop technology as what were called underlying elements. I think the case may still be ongoing though? This one went a long while.
And "not superior" is subjective. If the SawStop tech has enough false triggers and destroys as many blades as it apparently does based on what I've read (probably depends on material being cut), the increased cost almost certainly isn't worth it unless you're a high school shop class.
Meanwhile there wasn't even a mention of the sensing technology.
Yeah, that's bad. When you resort to lobbying, you're no longer on the good side of the ledger.
That's a foundation of democracy, really: the right to petition the government. I think you might want to re-examine your view a bit.
FANG has a phalanx of former electeds and staffers paid to hustle their former colleagues. To defend their grift and dismantle civil society. Grist for an endless torrent of outrage porn.
While pendants will argue both me and FANG are "lobbying", petitioning our governments, our respective efforts hardly seem comparable.
Adopting a policy is different from having them mandate what people buy.
Hey, have people buy epipens and keep one at the school for each kid with allergies. Then later we will raise our prices 1000 percent. That's not influencing policy, its fucking people all the way to the bank - with government assistance.
https://www.swnewsmedia.com/shakopee_valley_news/news/educat...
However, I don't find forcing everyone to have it by law to be particularly palatable.
I will tell you, however, that it goes off about once a month like clockwork and, as far as I can tell, it hasn't yet fired because someone was about to get injured (this is a good thing--it means our people aren't being stupid).
It's a $100-$200 hit every single time it fires. So, we have an ongoing expense of about $1500 every year for SawStop. That's a new saw every year.
Should that really be forced on people?
I will absolutely fight you on this tooth and nail.
1) I don't want anyone to get into the habit of turning off safety features. Ever.
2) If the material can be cut on that saw without the SawStop, it should be able to be cut with the SawStop. If it can't, the fault is with SawStop, not the user.
I'm happy to pay the extra money for the extra safety. However, I will NOT allow you to blame the user for the fact that SawStop has not uncommon failure modes.
If you turn off feature you are back to your regular saw - hopefully you use a stick etc in all cases because as you note replacing cartridges is expensive.
One thing I like, it'll put feature back on automatically for the next time machine gets turned on.
You also have to wait for the blade to come to a complete stop before touching anything or you will fire the system. This can be annoying when you have the motor turned off, retracted the blade, and start setting up your fence only to have the system fire because it wasn't quite stopped.
Was there a sticker on something that was slightly metallic? Oops.
I'm happy to have a SawStop on my saws, and I would even recommend it. However, given how often it false fires, I'm not sure I would mandate it by law.
Or have a noncartridge saw brake on the saw, when you come off saw for more than 3 seconds put some light pressure on to slow it more quickly.
I think a fair number of false fires are from this rather than the "wet wood" worry.
I was merely pointing out that saying you would never buy a sawstop for whatever crazy reason (ie, other companies wouldn't pay them the $3-$10 or whatever) seems a bit ridiculous.
If you have a fair number of folks using the saw, have them touch materials to saw first with saw off to get a read on it or list the ones not recommended.
$18K for a bottle of milk for a baby etc (trauma activation fees are crazy).