It would've made sense if it was a true offset, i.e. carbon capture in various forms. But "offsetting" carbon-positive activity with carbon-neutral is just bizarre. Where is my money for sitting on a couch instead of taking a plane to Australia?
Choosing to not take a flight to Australia, on the other hand, is just deciding to produce CO2, just less. That makes it categorically different, as it can't negate any amount of CO2 production.
Also, the supply of "not flying to Australia" is unbounded, and without scarcity, the price will naturally go to $0. If you only focus on potential fliers, that would have the perverse effect of incentivizing people to take actions intended to convince the regulators of this market that they were planning on flying to Australia, which would likely result in empty seats on flights to Australia and a net increase in the number of chartered flights to Australia.
This is indulgence trading, in my opinion.