It wasn't the U.S. retreat that turned these over to the Taliban. It was the unexpected, near-immediate dissolution of the Afghan military that did.
A journalist (Beau of the Fifth Column) I trust on topics such as this covers that, and other common questions regarding the last couple weeks. The equipment being left behind is the first couple minutes: https://youtu.be/KUMomGe4fjY
Aside from the gear, the loss of life is a glaring failure.
No. It doesn't. Your assertion that it was "left behind" is incorrect. The U.S. provided this equipment to the Afghan military as part of our long effort to prepare the Afghan government to defend itself.
Now, one can argue as to whether we should have entrusted such equipment to them in the first place. But, that entrustment was just one of many costly decisions made over our decades-long presence in Afghanistan that led up to this moment.
Also curious on your hot take of this—the unusually effective suicide bombings that took place last week, (y’know the ones that killed our servicemen and about a hundred innocent civilians?), were very likely composed of the very same high explosives that we left behind.
I don't know what you're defining as being "still in a position" or what your basis is for that determination, but we all witnessed that chaos ensued quickly upon the collapse of the Afghan govt/military. At that point, it seems the priority was on saving lives and extricating human beings which was meeting with significant difficulty to say the least.
That's a much more plausible explanation for why decommissioning the equipment was not prioritized.
The situation is bad. The 20-year occupation itself was horrible foreign policy. But just making unfounded allegations of "corruption" is FUD.
I found the "y'know..." bit a little flip, given the tragic circumstances.
In any case, my "hot take" on that narrow point is that it's another unfounded assertion that reads like more FUD.
On the broader point, there are many people politicizing this and working overtime to assign as much blame as possible to the current administration, including what you appear to be doing here.
And, my hot take on that broader point is that it's divisive and uses the tragic deaths of our fallen military and the grief of their families as political props.
The unbridled glee in their political attacks is palpable, even as our country and military are experiencing a significant setback that includes the loss of life. It's disgusting and, whatever they think they're rooting for, it's not America.
8 months in office and practically unlimited resources (human and material), and this is the best they could come up with. Joe Biden was a senator when Saigon was evacuated.
No there’s not enough work here to go into overtime.
Yet, here you are.
But, congratulations to you though. The fact that a 20-year foreign policy blunder culminated on the 8-month watch of a president you don't like clearly somehow seems like a personal victory for you, even if it comes at the expense of American and Afghan lives.
Those of us who are actually rooting for America are disappointed in some aspects of the withdrawal, as well as the fact that we'd been there for so long in the first place.
And, glad to finally have a president with the courage to get us out, thus finally ending the unfortunate expenditure of American blood and treasure going forward.
Trump negotiated the exit strategy to ‘get us out’, Biden just couldn’t execute it.
> But, congratulations to you though. The fact that a 20-year foreign policy blunder culminated on the 8-month watch of a president you don't like clearly somehow seems like a personal victory for you, even if it comes at the expense of American and Afghan lives.
There is no victory here for anyone, except America’s enemies. You know, there are people in the world, that are able to criticize terrible leadership, without relishing said leaderships failures. It’s binary thinking like yours that keep us in this two-party partisan nightmare.
If you want to continue making this a partisan thing, then at least be consistent.
If Trump wanted the political credit for actually executing the plan, then he should have executed it. After all, he ran on that as a promise and had 4 years to execute it, whereas Biden was only there for 8 months, as you've pointed out.
A negotiated date is not an exit plan in any case, and many believe only served to box in the incoming administration.
>There is no victory here for anyone, except America’s enemies.
Glad to hear you say that. But, if you want people to believe that you actually believe it, then you should temper your obvious hyper-partisan glee and stop with the politicization of our service-members' deaths; to include peddling unfounded conspiracy theories regarding imagined "corruption" yielding the materials used to attack our troops.
This is exactly the kind of disinformation that our enemies use to diminish our standing on the world stage, demoralize our military and citizenry, and divide us further.
Criticizing our leadership is one thing, and I've expressed my disappointment in some of the execution here as well. But, peddling propaganda and conspiracy theories against your own country is taking up the role of useful idiot, at best.
Everyone who says this us deluded about the depth of failure that led to the withdrawal and the constraints that placed on the execution of the withdrawal. We couldn't make the Afghan government forces not collapse instantly, nor could we (productively, at least) reinvade to replace them and provide the capacity to operate more broadly during the withdrawal.
You’d get much better insight from asking historians or the like.
Sounds like the powers that be read the most optimistic projections of what the Afghan Army could do on paper and ignored or suppressed any information to the contrary. Simply a lack of integrity and not hearing what they didn't want to hear.
And violating the agreements with the Taliban about withdrawal of forces to do that would make it easier or harder for people to get to Kabul to be evacuated?
> Sounds like the powers that be read the most optimistic projections of what the Afghan Army could do on paper and ignored or suppressed any information to the contrary
Given the already-executed surrender, the options were:
(1) throw it out and start a new war,
(2) rely on the Afghan Army providing security,
(3) rely on minimizing offense/provocation to the Taliban in the course of the evacuation.
I don't think there was much optimism about #2; there was projecting the right public image to avoid sabotaging what chances that held, but the fallback was #3, because #1 not only isn't viable for the withdrawal itself, but also is the worst possible thing to attempt for the post-withdrawal political situation.
You really think this could not have gone worse?
It's like you're not understanding.