This is absolutely false/misleading [1], and I don't understand why it's so present in the news (tabloids?) right now.
1. See 13th word: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivermectin
This is absolutely false/misleading [1], and I don't understand why it's so present in the news (tabloids?) right now.
1. See 13th word: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivermectin
“Joe Rogan says he's contracted coronavirus, is treating it with ivermectin”
https://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/joe-rogan-contracted-c...
I’m simply trying to point out that people believing that can treat themselves with unproven drugs and skipping vaccines …
Anyway, a thousand Americans will die today, mostly unvaccinated. I sure hope people figure it out soon.
Also, for context: https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/brief/covid-19-continues...
https://twitter.com/andrewdouglass/status/133633600349835264...
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/medrxiv/early/2021/01/06/202...
=====
* The Pierre Kory paper that started it all: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8088823. Pierre is a front-line clinician that fights to figure out how to treat symptomatic patients, thus he has understandable biases.
* The Tess Lowrie metastudy claiming clinical properties: https://journals.lww.com/americantherapeutics/fulltext/2021/... The effects mostly vanished when an Egyptian study was proven to use false data.
* There is a pre-covid body of work documenting anti-viral properties of Ivermectin.
* There is a pre-covid body of work documenting anti-inflammatory properties of Ivermectin.
* There is a wide body of work documenting safety of Ivermectin in humans. The 2015 Nobel prize in medicine was awarded for the discovery of Ivermectin.
* There is some credible work that documents Ivermectin have some small effect in decreasing covid severity. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28351973 for some links. But there is other credible work that says it has no effect.
* There are some claims that introducing Ivermectin in a geographical area (some Indian states) correlates with a rapid decline of a covid epidemic outbreak. Alas, covid epidemic outbursts are spike shaped, so it is hard to say if Ivermectin had an effect or the outburst flamed out naturally.
* Some tropical countries where Ivermectin is routinely prescribed had low rates of sever covid outbreaks. This led some to believe Ivermectin has a hand in it. Alas, the age pyramid in those countries is leans young vs. age pyramid in the rest of the world leaning old. Given that covid is orders of magnitudes less dangerous for young people, this by itself explains disparities in covid severity outbreaks.
* There is a number of bulls**t websites that do 'meta-analyses' from low credibility poorly cited sources. Ignore.
* There is a ridiculously acrimonious Twitter fight between 'Ivermectin is a horse medicine that kills grandma' and 'Ivermectin is a covid-erasing magic wand' camps. I shudder at the hell a poor soul that wants to research 'there appears to be a weak signal in Ivermectin against covid, let's investigate deeper' must go through.
Since Ivermectin is mostly being hyped (and, often using veterinary formulations, abused) as a treatment rather than pre-diagnosis preventive, wouldn't a more appropriate contrast be Ivermectin vs. monoclonal antibody treatment?
To your point, I've heard reasonable Ivermectin proponents arguing that it works best as a preventive and/or started early after infection. To the infamous Youtube moment where somebody took preventive Ivermectin on camera.
See https://twitter.com/BrettWooldridge/status/14127683829365022...
Those sold without prescribed are not for human use. Lower quality, different dose etc. People are buying those and getting very sick.
It's also much harder to get safe dose from product intended to animals. People taking animal medicine are in danger of liver injury.
This is how the tobacco industry avoided liability for decades after research conclusively demonstrated the hazards of smoking and other forms of tobacco use.
> 2. link to a not-very-authoritative and easily manipulated source that has been edited very recently to promote uncertainty and doubt
Are you suggesting that the Wikipedia page is wrong and Ivermectin is not used for humans? The brand name is Stromectol [2][3].
2. Guidelines for human consumption: https://www.merck.ca/static/pdf/STROMECTOL-PM_E.pdf
3. FDA approval for that manufacturer: https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cder/daf/index.cfm?ev...
I knew this question would come up. The problem with Wikipedia isn't that it's wrong. It's that it's usually technically correct, and that it takes an expert in the topic to point out where articles, while not stating anything factually incorrect, nevertheless fail to accurately convey understanding of the topic.
In other words, Wikipedia is usually "right enough" for many topics, especially non-controversial ones, that people generally accept it as correct.
Things like the NPOV rule mean that you often see bogus "all sides" content, the lack of enforcement of the reliability guidelines for sources, and so forth make it possible for articles to obfuscate reality.
In this case, we have people pointing to Wikipedia saying "look, it's approved for human use" and citing other sources as a way to intentionally confuse and raise doubt about whether or not the drug is effective for COVID-19.
In fact, no studies have shown it has any value for COVID, but the misinformation is to ignore that and keep pointing out that it's not just a horse de-wormer, that it's approved for certain uses in humans, and encourage the reader to wonder if maybe the FDA can't be trusted, or that experts on SARS-COV-2 are wrong, and so forth.
It's the same tactics used by the tobacco companies, as I mentioned, and also global warming denialists and proponents of DDT. I recommend reading Erik M. Conway and Naomi Oreskes book Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Climate Change
And stop quoting Wikipedia.
Arguing over what Ivermectin can or can't do or how that fact is presented is simply a way to keep the discussion "in doubt".
Ivermectin has no therapeutic value for COVID-19 and in the form commonly available as a veterinary medication can be harmful. End of story.