I accidently discovered the benefits of writing code on pencil and paper some years ago when I was looking for a career change. I picked up a C book that had exercises in it but only had time to go through the book during my commute on the metro. Because I worked in a SCIF I couldn't take any electronics with me to work. So I would read a section the night before, go to bed, and churn out the lab solutions in a notebook on the metro. At the time I thought these circumstances were slowing my progress. Once my circumstances changed and I had the time to do everything with two monitors and every IDE on the internet, I was bogged down.
I am not a developer, but occassionally need to write code. I always go to the paper first now.