It's interesting in that it talks about both server and client side scanning, and some of the things that WhatsApp does.
An interesting fact from the article: in 2020, Whatsapp made 400,000 reports to the NCMEC. Apple: 265
It's interesting in that it talks about both server and client side scanning, and some of the things that WhatsApp does.
An interesting fact from the article: in 2020, Whatsapp made 400,000 reports to the NCMEC. Apple: 265
There's a big difference though between scanning a library (which is closer to what DropBox/OneDrive are doing) and when it's messaging platform whose ultimate goal is communication between people. It does make sense that those catch way more.
If Apple had roll those scans on iMessage attachements (which they didn't planned to, though the feature looked to be designed for it way more than it was for a library scan), you would probably see comparable numbers (modulo those platforms relative marketshares).
One big problem though is are those large numbers actually actionable ? I think I remember seeing a quote from Swiss (?) law enforcement that complained that the reports they got from NCMEC were nearly all of the time unactionable.
There are possibly many reasons from this, it could be differences in local laws, algorithms that wrongly report things, or other factors (maybe not enough to identify the user of the acount, etc).
This is where one feature of Apple's design was a bit better: they didn't plan to report every single occurence, but would only if 30 such images were detected. Part of the reason they did was because of the imperfections of the NeuralHash mechanism, sure, but in the end it doesn't matter.
One can argue doing this would at least generate more actionnable reports. It shouldn't be a numbers game.
It sounds like simply being able to say "This user was messaging with 4 known offenders,and sending something the size of images" is unlikely to be helpful to law enforcement.
Does anyone really think we're only another 20 million reports a year away from solving the CSAM problem?
I might say that it's possible there are actions that can reduce, but not eliminate, the problem. What if another 20 million reports saved one child from exploitation? 10 children? 1000 children?
At some level, this boils down to a society question. We all agree CSAM is evil. How does it stack up against other things we think are evil? I fear that, in the end, there is no middle ground that includes eliminating CSAM and keeping 100% privacy.