Hacker News Reader

Comment by obedm | Hacker News Reader

I lived in cities all my life, until two years ago when I moved to the very green suburbs of Budapest.

Now, Whenever we go to the city, I notice how much it stinks.

It's so weird because I never noticed that before. My nose for used to "clean" hair now. And I don't even live away from the road.

I'd like to move even more into the woods.

View on HN

This might depend on which city you refer to. For example, I wouldn't say that Stockholm has any discernable smell to it.

Stockholm is built on islands that helps, and the rains are not frequent but heavy enough to clean the city a bit, waste management is good. Thera are also fewer people are active in the center of Stockholm compared to Paris; Stockholm 5 214 pop/km², Paris 20 909 pop/km² (this disregards important factors about how those numbers work, but it's an interesting indication.)

I notice it's worse in cities with extremely dense urban cores, like NYC. There was a distinct smell (not just garbage, but something I basically call 'the NYC smell' in my head) in many parts. Other cities never seemed quite so bad; at least not bad enough I can still remember that smell.

I've never been to NYC, but I've heard that waste management infrastructure is not great there. Could that be contributing to bad smells?

Maybe Stockholm has plenty of wind? Big cities tend to stink. Didn't bother me until my 30s, now I can barely tolerate the smell, not just the fact that it kills us.

But hey, people want cars. Lots of dirty but cheap cars. Almost nobody seems to care. It's just the nature of living in a poor country I guess.

Stockholm isn't particularly windy.

I think cars generally contribute to bad smells, and poor waste management infrastructure can also contribute to bad smells (think garbage bins out on streets instead of enclosed, for example)

It's situated on an archepilago in the Baltic sea. Sure, it might be less windy than other coastal cities, but Stockholm is far windier than cities in-land.

Stockholm has tolls to reduce road congestion though. The place was definitely smellier back in the 90's.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com