Speak against the government--you're no longer allowed to transact in society.
Retroactive tax...boom, negative balance.
We agree on the problem, but not the solution. Technology does not solve challenges at the people/politics OSI layer.
[1] https://www.visualcapitalist.com/700-year-decline-of-interes...
The solution to real productivity declines is real productivity increases, and the incentive to reallocate your resources into the most productive activities is lacking when the cost of capital is effectively nil and the central bank bails out any misallocation.
Societies that realize this implement debt forgiveness policies such as https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jubilee_(biblical) and modern bankruptcy and inflation. Societies that fail to do this stagnate, with many in them trapped by debt slavery.
Slow growing stagnant societies lose competitions for resources to societies that implement debt forgiveness. Sometimes stagnant societies implode in civil wars and revolutions as happened in France, Russia, China. This also results in wealth gaps shrinking but at far greater cost.
I don't know why but when the central bank intends lower interest rates to overheat the market people somehow stop believing that the market even exists. It's really strange. I mean it. People talk about how the market works and will fix everything on its own but as soon as there is any government action even action that supports the market suddenly people think it will completely break down, as if the market didn't exist or function the way they say.
Bankruptcy and unemployment are the means with which we "prioritize and allocate resources". They are, by definition, when you stop doing what you were doing and start doing something else. So no, I would disagree that "governments are begging for this to happen" - I can't think of a government that's encouraged bankruptcy and unemployment since the 1980s.
I view various forms of capital as a way to get over local maxima in economic efficiency. You borrow money or raise funds now so that you can build up tooling and innovations that will let you work more efficiently in the future, and then if you're right, you make lots of profits and can pay back your loans & dividends. If you're wrong, you go bankrupt, your investors take a haircut, and that capital goes back to other more productive activities.
Constantly growing debt balances and inflation, however, I view as a way of lying to ourselves. They're basically saying "Well, in the future, things will get better", but when the future arrives and you still don't have profits, shrink the yardstick so things look better. That's exactly what "government action that supports the market" is - it's a way to avoid the failure of enterprises and loss of jobs that the market, on its own, doesn't demand enough to make profitable. Do this over 90 years and you can get some pretty extensive misallocation of capital.
Inflation is the economy’s rate of debt forgiveness. Bad when high but good when low but above zero. Without it economies get clogged by debt. A slow rate of debt forgiveness is more economically efficient than bankruptcies or debt jails. Inflation also combats sticky prices by forcing contracts to be regularly renegotiated to supply demand prices. For example wages are hard to adjust down and having inflation do that automatically few % per year is more economically efficient than having to fire workers and replace them.
China has the most restrictive capital controls in the world. It is not surprising at all that they have banned a legitimate threat to their control over the country's money.
"When the ships come into harbour, nail them to the dock" - not realizing that eventually, when the tide goes out - the ship will go down several feet relative to the dock and be damaged by the fixed boarding blanks.
You have to use ropes to fix ships, because the water moves.
Dumping the Central Bank and even using hard currency would lead to economic collapse the very first time there is an existential shock - and the only 'saviour' would be a different form of monetary intervention i.e. fiscal policy (i.e. government budget).
Also, in a completely unregulated scenario, powerful financial interests would leverage ownership of the crypto scheme and power would even be further centralized.
Bitcoin is disproportionately owned by a small number of players who have absolutely zero civic perspective, they're looking to make a Trillion dollars out of nothing.
If you don't like that money is managed by a large swath of banks working together with government and regulatory oversight and frankly relative transparency ... then you really won't like it when your monetary system is managed by the insane tyrant offspring of the Winkelvi and Satoshi dynasties who own 30% of the economy.
Crypto mining that is energy intensive should be banned immediately on that basis alone.
Aside from that, anyone declaring monetary value on a crypto asset should have to declare it, and if they don't, they go to actual prison for tax evasion. I'm looking forward to those people replacing weed smokers in prison - that would be effective public policy.
You're both pro legalization of weed and pro government? The war drugs is one the many fronts of the war on personal freedom.
Ironically the thing you're railing against -- being an anonymous uncensured transaction platform -- is one of the few ways weed dealers and consumers can continue to transact.
> Crypto mining that is energy intensive should be banned immediately on that basis alone.
Which is only neccessary to prevent
> Also, in a completely unregulated scenario, powerful financial interests would leverage ownership of the crypto scheme and power would even be further centralized.
PoS _is_ succeptible to this as ownership means a voting stake. PoW prevents entrenched interests from controlling it.
The kind of straw manning that reveals itself here due to the complete lack of civic thinking in some circles is really disturbing.
There is no necessity for mass energy usage for crypto, there are any number of ways to distribute new units of currency. Again the use of the term 'necessary' here is a hint at the false understanding of currency through the lens of a particular form of crypto.
Crytpo, at least today, is a dystopia. Go and live for a few weeks in a country with weak civic institutions and see for yourself. This joke is less and less funny as time goes on, the experiment, in it's current form, has run it's course, it's long since over.
I used to love the idea of the government fixing societies' woes. Unfortunately in my lifetime I've seen several business cycles wherein the rich get bailouts and the rest of us lose our shirts. My country has entered wars I didn't then, and don't now support. I've seen 3 letter agencies topple foreign governments, and I'm watching China leverage its social credit system and implementing CBDCs. I've seen the infrastructure in my country become dilapidated and homelessness skyrocket. I voted for 'change' and got none.
I am civic minded, and to me the government is starting to look like the problem. As such, I support any peaceful alternative. There is no such thing as consent of the governed, and I plan continue believing what I see with my lying eyes.
Tax the damn land and do negative interest rates on cash and use the negative interest to pay for the deposit insurance.
That's it. Bonus: Get rid of other regressive taxes. Lower income tax, corporate income tax, capital gains tax, sales tax, VAT and so on. Rather than redistributing incomes redistribute jobs.
In a world where economic rents are eliminated, income = spending is true on an individual and country level and jobs are fairly allocated there is no need for charity and welfare. It would be one small step closer to utopia yet it will not happen because nobody will recognize it as a "free market" that is supposedly the be and end all of economics even though it would be free-er than anything the capitalists will come up with.
Yes, here is the homework: If the solution is so simple how come there are so many people wanting to keep the system unfair and rigged?
Here is my answer: It's because the rich need to trick people into believing that the source of inequality is fair and morally justifiable. After all, if inequality has no place in a moral framework then any source of inequality would be tackled immediately.
So your "solution" is a regression to something that was tried and didn't actually work well? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_central_banking_in_...
A lot of the things that are happening now are not new. Sure, actors have changed, events have new facade and technology adds an interesting spin to it, but at its core, none of it is new to people who are aware of human history.
Separately, I will add that there are developments where 40 years is genuinely not long. As an example allow me to trot out the change of being gay being classified as a mental disorder in 80s to today's predominant understanding as a fully functioning member of society. That is a stunning evolution of societal mores in a short amount of time.
I suppose I understand that people would like to see instant change, but at certain scales, 45 years is 'not so long ago'. From societal memory point of view, it isn't. Only fool forgets that government can take their property. I will illustrate that further with a geological example. By those timescales, humans just showed up yesterday.