I really, really, dislike the modern flat colour designs of today. They make it much harder for me to separate out what I care about, like context and information, because my eyesight isn't perfect.
Gradients made it so much easier for me to see the difference between a tab and the bar it's sitting in. A little strip of colour or some shadowing, to denote the active tab just disappears for me.
(I'm sure there are even better examples of this "no gradients, but strong color contrast" effect among the various Linux Desktop Environment themes, but I'm not too familiar with them. Paging anyone from /r/unixporn.)
Give me contrast by using a mix of gradients and flat, any day.
I would note that Windows XP also had a high-contrast theme; and that, when enabled, inactive tabs actually lose the distinction in background color from active tabs. But they keep the highlight stripe.
To try and put it another way, imagine, for a moment, that you are incapable of perceiving edges. Every single one of your flat tabs now looks like the same part of the same blob.
Now, realise that for a pretty high number of low-vision people, that is reality. The slight blur we experience makes most edges disappear.
(WinXP's high contrast overcame this by tripling the size of all edges).
Switching tab is easy enough, by clicking the centre of its label. When you wish to switch tab, you generally are going to read the label.
But when working out where you are, that can be total guesswork.
A lot of UI design on computers of the era was flat colors, maybe with a mild gradient. Go look up screenshots from Windows 3.1. Everything is flat grey or white. Windows 9x wasn't really much better, except it had that ugly solid teal background.
Also, dithering on a CRT produced a very different effect from dithering on a high-res LCD.
And the "modern flat solid color designs" still use stuff like subtle shadows and transparencies that would have been either impossible or wouldn't have looked nice in the nineties...
I happen to like the dithered look, but arguably it might not be the best way to save on bandwidth.
I would be all for this, but I frequently find myself pinch-zooming into images on my phone to more closely examine the details in them. If the site assumed that I would only see what's visible in the image at the initially-rendered aspect ratio, then zooming would reveal nothing (e.g. text that's small and blurry, would just become large and blurry, rather than crisp.)
Ideally, a browser would be able to notice when you've zoomed into an image element past its Nyquist frequency, and async-load a higher-quality version of the image, swapping it out once the loading's complete. Do any browsers do this yet?