2) If you dislike Cuban's target for investment (fixing unemployment, the purported goal of the Tea Party and GOP), then please, by all means, pick a different avenue by which the government could make a return on investment.
2) If you dislike Cuban's target for investment (fixing unemployment, the purported goal of the Tea Party and GOP), then please, by all means, pick a different avenue by which the government could make a return on investment.
Yes, I think perhaps maybe the government should not be doing what a business would do in this situation.
Again, I remind you I'm not actually trying to engage in a debate over proper economics in general (and trying very hard to carefully refrain from injecting too much of my opinion, it took me a few edits on the first message), I'm trying to work out what exactly this post is trying to say. It isn't clear to me at all how Cuban gets from the the government of today, which is incapable of allocating capital, to the government of tomorrow, which when presented with a menu of even more decisions than it has to make today, is then capable of allocating capital intelligently in an even tougher decision-making environment. Why would the government not simply fail in the ways it is failing already in the allocation of capital? What's the connecting step?
So, what would you do when faced with an investor who's a complete fucking idiot, but can borrow money cheaply?
What is a fail-proof investment plan for this trustifarian?
Why can't we find a plan, or demand that our government do something with this opportunity? There is a hack to be had in here. Who can we trust with this opportunity that the government can farm it out to? What would the terms have to be in order to ensure that the government can make a return?
btw, upvotes for you, thanks for the conversation :)
... tell him not to borrow money?
Is that really such a strange idea?
In fact... how can you seriously entertain any other answer? (In this case, limited to the investor case, not the investor as a standin for the government. This may or may not apply to the government, but what is this metaphor supposed to be proving, anyhow...?)
One of the human irrationalities is a belief that for any set of constraints there must be a solution, but that's not true. An "idiot" investor has no winning solution (virtually by definition in this case), and therefore the answer is not to play. There is no force in the universe that says there must still be a way to invest and prosper anyhow.
Instead, they are the scorekeeper and it seems by the current debate that there is many people that doesn't understand this.
--> infrastructure projects!
If it is a given that money can be borrowed for basically zero interest rate, why not invest it at long term low yield infrastructure projects such as: roads/bridges, high speed trains, electrical distribution networks, or my personal favourite: scientific research.
A WPA-type program to improve transportation, energy and communications infrastructure. Lot's of jobs across many sectors, from professional to artistic to skilled & unskilled labor, most of which can be in the private sector (contractors/contracting firms).
We tried that and can't do it today. Instead, we piss away large amounts of money and don't build infrastructure.
Policy recommendations should account for reality, not "if we do this right".
When? ARRA was sold as that, but it became more about tax cuts and propping up state governments that a public works program.
> and can't do it today.
We're going to have to do it some point: http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/
May as well do it now while people are out of work and interest rates are low.
> When? ARRA was sold as that, but it became more about tax cuts and propping up state governments that a public works program.
And your new program won't be that because ....?
We can also look at currrent infrastructure spending. It's basically all jobs program, starting with the Davis-Bacon requirement.
> We're going to have to do it some point: http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/
> May as well do it now while people are out of work and interest rates are low.
Um, the facts that we need to do it and now would be a good time to do it do not imply that we'd actually do it.
We're doing a lot of infrastructure spending now. How about fixing it before embarking on an expansion? That way, we won't have wasted a lot of money that could be used when we're actually going to fix infrastructure.
Yes, interest rates are low now, but lenders want their principle back as well, so wasting money now can affect our ability to borrow and spend when we're serious.
There are upgrades to be had: HSR (where it makes sense), more modern air traffic control, intelligent transport systems, multimodal facilities, high-speed internet, power generation (green or otherwise), smart grid, flood contro, seismic refits, etc.
But we don't even need to discuss upgrading the infrastructure, most of what we have now is subpar because of decades of deferred or non-existent maintenance. We will need to spend billions just to get our existing systems up to par,
TODAY. However, do you really think that interest rates will remain low until that money is paid off?
The point that others have brought up is that if the US Government borrows an incredibly large amount of money and pushes up the Debt/GDP ratio, future, additional borrowing will become more expensive. But if today's borrowing is used efficiently, it should drive up GDP and reduce some of the need for future borrowing.
TIPS aren't fixed rate, but I don't know what fraction of new US debt is TIPS.
More to the point, you're assuming that we won't have to roll-over that debt, which only happens if we're not running a deficit. Since we are for the forseeable future....
Your second point is, of course, right on. But if we have to borrow $x, better to borrow it now at ~0% than later at (likely) >0% interest.
According to that reasoning, interest rates almost never change because they're typically a given premium to inflation.
We don't accept that reasoning because you repay what the note says, not the relationship between that number and some other number.
> Your second point is, of course, right on. But if we have to borrow $x, better to borrow it now at ~0% than later at (likely) >0% interest.
Umm, no. Borrowing now at 0% and rolling that over later to a new loan at 10% is not better than simply borrowing later at 10%.
Yes, borrowing now is better if you do something useful now with the money, something that you'd delay by borrowing later.
However, there's little evidence of that occurring. We're running up lots of debt on dumb spending. If you want to do some smart spending, take the money from dumb spending.
For long-term lending, as long as the Fed doesn't change its stance, the rates will only go up if the economy recovers. If the economy recovers, government won't have to borrow that much anymore.
And if you were still unhappy about the interest payment of government, the government could just change the way its monetary policy is implemented and push down the yields of long-term bonds as well. After all, the government administrates the US$ monetary system. Operationally, they would just instruct the Fed to target long-term yields as well, and then the Fed would change them in the same way that it changes short-term yields (by doing open market operations).
So, er, yes, sounds like that might be a reasonable assumption?