This is just like bitcoin in 2011.
This is just like bitcoin in 2011.
Bitcoin at least has theoretical uses, although practically it is definitely a negative force in the world. Their current price does not logically make them useful.
What about games, or art?
If I buy a print of and associated license to art, I gain the legal ability to look at and resell my copy the art.
If I invest and buy the copyright to something, I can sell the above rights to others.
If I pay to record on a blockchain my ownership a hash, I gain...nothing. I guess I could brag about how I paid money for a hexadecimal string when no one else was willing to? The theoretical advantage is that I can try to pawn it off on someone else for more money by convincing him that he can do the same to someone else.
If I buy an NFT, I gain the defacto ability to resell my copy the art.
If you buy just an NFT and send the US registered artwork itself along with it to the buyer, that's copyright infringement, and the original artist could sue you for thousands of dollars.
The IRS sure seems to think that I owned bitcoin.
An NFT is not a "copy of a the art". That's the part that you got wrong.
That's quite confrontational, if this topic is making you upset I'll refrain from continuing.
> If I buy an NFT, I gain the defacto ability to resell my copy the art.
and telling you exactly why I think your statement is wrong. Why do you think this is confrontational? This is a discussion forum.
Since it's not actually a copy, there's no first sale doctrine license to the copyright, making it illegal to have a copy of the art unless you have a separate licensing agreement. And if you do have such an agreement, that's the thing giving practical value.
You and I can agree that a rock represents your car, but I'm still not going to pay you for it.
This is why no one is buying and selling digital artworks, except using an artificial concept of ownership - a certificate. The artworld has done it with paper certificates for a long time; NFTs are the same thing.
You seem confused. A certificate does not grant ownership. The reason nobody is buying and selling digital images is because producing an exact copy of a digital image costs nothing, which means it's irrational to pay for a copy of an image since you can make a copy yourself for free.
Are there any surveys or something on how much gamers care about NFTs in their games? Because if there's no such data I can't think of a single reason for publishers to care about this.
The implementations get me a bit angry.
They enable criminals to extort and launder funds.
They've led to massive profits for speculators at the expense of ignorant people throwing their own money into the bubble.
They haven't benefited the average person at all.
Bitcoin wastes monumentous amounts of energy, raising the price for everyone else and further polluting the earth; it has wild value fluctuations, making it completely unusable as a currency; and it has no underlying value.
Then NFTs aren't even really ownership. You're buying the right to record a ownership of a hash. It just makes people feel like they own something unique. If you actually want to buy a digital assets without an intermediary, you contact the creator of a work and have him e-sign a contract giving you the copyrights in it. Boom. No need for a intermediary like OpenSea to skim its 2.5% off the top like NFTs do in practice, and you actually gets real rights in the work. People just don't do that because they don't want to actually give up something of actual value, they just want to rip people off, and because it's boring. NFTs are just a fad.
I suspect there will be more opportunities for NFTs to change my mind in the future with governance, but that risks them stepping into SEC governed territory.