Personally I got tired of being interested in something and finding out that it's not useable. The new playbook seems to be make screenshots, set up a landing page, and see if it goes viral on Product Hunt.
I think the mindless praise is also because some are a part of some cohort or ring, where they all promote each other.
The last time I saw something I used from PH was probably about 4 years ago and I'm still subscribed to the newsletter hoping for something new.