That's my question too.
I wrote a multiplayer strategy game back in mid 90's issuing floating point and it was deterministic. No problems. Maybe chip optimizations have affected this?
We looked at fixed point, but with careful scheduling we'd get zero fpu (x87) stalls for float operations, so it wasn't a real win to go fixed. And it gave us the benefit of having more registers to use without needing to use the main stack as much, which also made the asm easier to read.
Edit: typos