I carved turnips when I was younger, maybe only 30 (previously said 40) years ago. Pumpkins were expensive back then and the tradition, for my parents when they were younger, back in Ireland was to carve a turnip. You would do it much the same except you would add a handle and be able to carry it around with you at night. It was a lot more work to carve but it was great for trick or treating, especially when cheap torches were not so easily available.