The way I handle it is essentially never setting up automatic thread locking, and then, default to closing the issue, unless I add some specific label.
This is mostly for my sanity. There's a lot of issues where you get an issue raised with "x doesn't work", with little to no information. Great, I can't do anything with that, so I push back, and often you don't hear anything back. At this point, I close it (or rather, stale bot does after inactivity). If the user then provides more information and the issue is triaged and valid, I add a label, which makes sure stale bot does not close the issue.
If an issue does get closed, I'll get a notification if someone ends up commenting, and I can take appropriate action. It also gives others the opportunity to comment if they can provide additional context.