No, quite the opposite in fact. CPI is a accurate measure of inflation as it tracks how much the real-world consumer prices vary where it really matters: real-world consumer expenses.
Perhaps the mistake you're making is assuming wrongly that demand for specific brands/makes/models is perfectly inelastic and consumers do not change their consumption patterns at all even if their price increases so much that they can no longer afford them. Meanwhile, if a low/middle class family sees the price of stake skyrocket, you can bet they'll start to switch a few meals to hamburguers or hotdogs.