I suspect CDE was designed to still work on monochrome displays, but color is imho very important for effective interfaces and CDE doesn't use it at all.
To say something like this is a bit funny in the world where "light" and "dark" are theme choices. If anything has tried to use colorful desktop, it is VUE, CDE, today NsCDE etc.
Or did you mean the actual drop shadow, outside the window proper?
But my point is that the effects are often so subtle they can't even be noticed. I'm not against them per se. I have most of them on now in KDE in fact but boosted up a bit which I think looks nicer.
But you're right, it's not a 'big load' like I said, a modern GPU can handle this with 2 fingers up its nose.
There's a lot to be said for distinctive, beveled buttons for quick visual acquisition of interactive UI widgets. Modern fashion trends make them look dated, but I'd be willing to put money on them being quicker for new users of an application getting oriented and doing things.
Right to the point. A pure visual and usability masochism. I live for the day when our buttons, menus, scrollbars and such will one again have topShadowColor and bottomShadowColor, inverted on click to have nice fat juicy feeling that something has beed clicked actually.
Even MFC, although lower level than Borland offerings, is much better than plain Win32.
Using bare bones Win32 is only for masochists that sweare for C's "simplicity".
Although Windows team seems to have enough of them, so nowadays legacy MFC or Qt/VCL are a much better experience than XAML C++, given the lack of Visual Studio tooling for it.
Pulling another straw man, are we?
Plenty of other comments to read here.
The loss of "chrome" in today's modern UIs makes undiscoverability a huge problem.
I had to learn that people exits who like flat gray on dark gray non-intuitive, sick and depressively looking "modern" interfaces with huge visual and thematic choices: usually called "light" and "dark" - all this wierdness in 2021.
So yes, we can try to exterminate each other, or learn to live with this fact about differencies, and let other live.
De gustibus non est disputandum.