ElementaryOS did this with their Pantheon and it's the reason I moved from them to Pop_OS. Their apps were generally useless or broken, critical basic settings (fractional DPI, per monitor dpi, etc) were missing and weird bugs abound. I had to install the dconf editor just to get the damn screen readable on my XPS.
Pop_OS at the moment is just about perfect since it's just a well tuned gnome theme basically. So far I've only hit one bug and one odd default setting.