I am an electronics engineer. I have learned much more electronics from the manuals of some Hewlett-Packard products than from most University courses.
Besides their excellent product manuals, which explained everything needed to understand how their products operated and how they can be repaired or modified, the company also published "HP Journal", which explained in great detail why and how their more important products were designed.
The kind of documentation that HP produced was invaluable training for generations of engineers.
Looking at the garbage documentation generated now by almost everybody for their products, it seems almost unbelievable that such companies like the old HP ever existed.
Quite a few HP products - like its programmable pocket calculators, and some of the test equipment - were legendary for their engineering.
HP Inc is a completely different outfit and seems to have none of the original spirit left.
Whether it's even possible to create a broadly positive company culture that can survive contact with modern MBAs and investors is debatable.
I wonder what the reaction is in MBA school when this topic comes up? Does the teacher say it's not applicable in today's world? It's obviously shunned by most. Can any of these ideas still work in 2021?
So their reaction would be positive, like "HP was such a good company! I love all of their business principles and I'd love to build a corporation known for good engineering, sound financial management, and promoting technically competent leaders." And then most promptly do none of that, focus on short term returns, and run a company into the ground.
Probably the most succinct setup for the MBA hate I have ever read. Classic.
Bill and Dave were still visiting the varied HP divisions in the late 1970s (when I went to work for HP in Colorado). Hewlett was succeeded by John Young as CEO in 1978. Both Hewlett and Packard left the board of directors in 1993.
It certainly is a very tough job to establish a good culture that can last the test of time. Compared to many other founders, though, I personally don't think they did that badly, though of course many others disagree. While HP itself lost its way in the 1990s, many of these ideals were adopted by other companies or taken to new companies by HP employees.
The HP Way was still popular and well known/followed even during the waning years of Carly Fiorina and for sometime after her departure.
I don’t understand why this would be a failure of the founders long after they moved out. Look at Google, which went as far as dethroning the “don’t be evil” mantra in its early teens. HP has probably kept its culture for several multiples of that before it was drowned out.
The business climate changes. As you say, CEOs change and HP arguably went through particular tumult in that regard with a generally lackluster Platt and then all the Fiorina-associated drama. (Who lugged "the garage" around from stage to stage but didn't really walk the walk as much as talked the talk.)
Times change in other ways as well. It's hard to compare how major computer companies operated and what the expectations were of employees in the 70s/80s compared to today. I expect if you average mid-level Google engineer were dropped into HP, IBM, Intel, or DEC ~1980, they'd probably find a lot to not like.
Are you talking about your opinion of the company “HP Inc” today?
IMO it is not surprising that companies change a lot in 60 years (or 40).
P.S. the original HP is now Keysight, they are still premier for test & measurement equipment.
For example, HP Medical was also highly regarded, then went with Agilent and was later sold to Philips.
but I agree hp was split into a lot of companies, with a lot of good parts scattered widely (except AFAICT no good parts scattered into “HP Inc”)
"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something."