Its great to see the "routine-ness" - but SpaceX needs to stay humble and stay focused. A accident now could cost everything they have done to this point.
-- edited to clarify potential failure mode.
Its great to see the "routine-ness" - but SpaceX needs to stay humble and stay focused. A accident now could cost everything they have done to this point.
-- edited to clarify potential failure mode.
I'll never get over the fact that NASA never made an assessment of tile damage after liftoff in over 100 flights before Columbia. All these machines are experimental in the sense we still don't understand completely what happens with them and treating them like 737's is a huge mistake.
Even in the case of the 737, the MAX proved we didn't understand a 737 thoroughly enough to ensure safe operation.
> Even in the case of the 737, the MAX proved we didn't
> understand a 737 thoroughly enough to ensure safe operation.
Actually, we did. But it was thought economical to ignore proper engine placement and weight distribution, and make up for it with automated elevator trimming.Economical being a conservative word. Designing a new airframe for the newer, larger, more efficient engines would have been very expensive.
Columbia had a foam strike on the leading edge and wasn't so lucky.
On visits to the ISS it's 37 vs 25.
If you look at the ratio of non-human flights to human flights SpaceX is far more conservative of human life.
See Soyuz T-10a
> If it had been a crewed flight, the crew would not
> have boarded at that point.
SpaceX is unique in the field of human spaceflight in that they fuel the manned vehicles with the airmen already on board. It took quite some convincing to get NASA to allow this on NASA flights.The advantages are that if there is a problem before the astronauts are strapped in, firing the LES on a loaded rocket will seriously hurt the astronauts and ground crew. Also, with less time between propellant loading and launch, denser, super chilled propellants can be used. This provides significant margins for boostback and recovery of the first stage boosters.
Also wondering what the timeline comparison is here too. Wasn't one of the problems with Columbia the advanced age of the shuttle? I'm assuming this isn't comparable to the situation with spacex?
> Wasn't one of the problems with Columbia the advanced age of the shuttle?
No. The problem that led to the loss of Columbia was fundamental and well understood - if underestimated - since STS-1 was inspected after its first landing. > they will investigate the issue and build a safer one the next time
The parallels between the new Starship and the Comet are many. As excited as I am to see the new Starship flying, and I would fly it, I wouldn't want my children to fly on it.At least, not the landing part. If they could launch and perform all exatmospheric activities in a Starship yet land in a Dragon (or Soyuz) I'd be fine with that.
That said, SpaceX will probably be able to relaunch early Starships with a few months of their initial launches, and might be able to refurbish a Starship for launch within a few weeks in short order. I would not be surprised to see a single Starship perform three launches and landings by the end of 2022. We could see a dozen total Starship launches and landings in that same timeframe.
We might see people fly on it by 2023. That's not a long time.
How did you get to that conclusion regarding Crew Dragon?
With time and more flights, more things will have a chance to go wrong, and in spaceflight, resting on your laurels is the best way to make sure that when it does go wrong it will be catastrophic.
For example, the O-Rings were designed as a backup, the force generated by the solid rocket motors was supposed to seal the SRM sections together. But they knew after the first launch that the O-Rings were what was actually sealing the SRM's. But the O-Rings worked, so they didn't stop the program to fix the design. Later they found evidence of blow through the O-Rings, and again decided that since that didn't cause a crash, they were OK. Until they didn't. Tile strike damage was a similar normalization that killed 7 people.
Does SpaceX normalize deviance? They fixed the toilet, so they didn't normalize that, but what about the delayed opening of the 4th parachute in the Crew 2 landing? It seems suspicious that they launched Crew 3 so quickly after an apparent anomaly. They do claim that the delayed opening is nominal behaviour seen and accepted in testing -- that this behaviour only happens when the other 3 parachutes are working fine. If one of the others had failed the 4th would have opened quicker due to increased air pressure.
https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/11/double-dragon-nasa-p...
That NASA did not see the parachute as an issue speaks volumes. It looked bad visually, but having watched enough space launches and how mission control reacts to off-nominal data - clearly they were comfortable with the performance, because they didn't flinch at all. NASA just doesn't sign off on these commercial launches with NASA astronauts on board if they have any inkling that something won't go right - they aren't under the political pressure to "save the Shuttle program" or whatever.
I have more concern about NASA getting politically-imposed "go fever" with SLS.
More likely is a failure of the other extreme where if changes are normalized and something that seems sufficiently simple actually has an outsized impact on the craft. I think such a thing is still relatively unlikely given how much testing and modelling goes into all their changes but it's much more likely than catastrophic failure occurring due to known design deficiencies that are left because they haven't yet caused failures.
There's actually a video of the plane trying to recover with the COM so far back, it is horrific.
EDIT: The video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5fpxm0D46iQ
Because the loadmaster is a member of the aircrew they incentivized to be good at their job and veto unsafe loads because it's their life at stake if the aircraft becomes tail heavy in flight.
I'd love to see the causal relationship between both that makes it safe to land with 3 parachutes (I remember they added the 4th as an added precaution that reminds me of the O-ring issue)
This stuff is called rocket science for a reason.