> Passwords are secrets. Public keys are not. So the comparison doesn’t work.
These are not binary attributes. A public key absolutely can be a secret, and in many cases should be.
> If it was a public messaging service like HN, or public comments on Twitter or Facebook, then yes.
You're avoiding the question because in this case it isn't a "public messaging service." It's an attribute of an account configuration.
> Thus if privacy is a concern then you shouldn’t be using GitHub in the first place.
Nonsense. What if I use a private email for my github account? What if I only use private repositories?
You're repeatedly making an error of portraying privacy as black and white and it simply is not.
> I’m saying the SSH public keys are a lower risk than other details you share in GitHub.
No, you made a categorical, absolute statement that "If you need privacy then you shouldn’t be uploading to GitHub in the first place."
This statement is utter nonsense. Now you're just arguing that you didn't say what you actually said.
> That’s literally the point I’ve been making.
No, your statement that we're discussing was "If you need privacy then you shouldn’t be uploading to GitHub in the first place."
This statement is flatly incorrect. Your comments are demonstrably false, and your followups are irrelevant deflections.