Passwords are secrets. Public keys are not. So the comparison doesn’t work.
> Would you make the same comment about a conversation over a messaging service?
If it was a public messaging service like HN, or public comments on Twitter or Facebook, then yes.
> This is a configuration detail of an account setting -- not a blog post.
We could be here all day and night saying what this is or isn’t but it doesn’t address the point I was making. The moment you create a GitHub account you start leaking far more sensitive data than your public keys. Data that is far harder to create anonymously (unlike your SSH keys). Thus if privacy is a concern then you shouldn’t be using GitHub in the first place. Even git version control itself leaks information about you.
> Privacy is not binary; there are many shades of grey.
Ironic you state that when you’re the one applying privacy in a binary way. I’m saying the SSH public keys are a lower risk than other details you share in GitHub. Not that it’s a zero or 100% bad thing, which is the only pidgin holes you’re allowing for this discussion.
> It is surprising that this is made public and while it is not necessarily wrong to provide this service (I'm fine with it; I see the utility) it is also reasonable to ask for a way to opt out.
That’s literally the point I’ve been making.