Yep, though I agree with the parent, if a RAM returns data from a location that is different from what is stored in that location, assuming all recommended timings have been followed, then that RAM is defective. If that means they should be recommending a refresh after every single operation, then that's what it means.
In other words, the whole industry sits on a bed of lies at this point and it's only because government is technically incompetent that we haven't seen the world's biggest class-action.