The majority of these countries rank better on these metrics than the US does.
> This is with the notable exception of a few countries with vast natural resources providing an economic baseline
I can only think of one notable exception on that front, that being Norway with it's oil resources.
> more importantly a relatively small and homogenous population with similar needs and opinions
How exactly do you define "homogenous population" and why do you think "needs and opinions" are inherent to certain types of "population", which you apparently seem to use as a synonym for race?
The social system analogue to the US is not Canada, Canada's policies in that regard are way more resembling of European systems than the US's, that applies not only to welfare systems, but also crime and incarceration [0].
As such, Canada is very much an example of how at least part of these policies can also work in North America, even with its allegedly exceptional scale and diversity.
Actually, cultural traits penetrate all aspects of their economic system not just welfare system. For example due to social norms business competition between two businesses may not be as adversarial as it is normally seen in the US, unions are not as adversarial in relation to corporations and corporations are not as adversarial toward unions, government bureaucrats are not as adversarial (and boneheaded) toward businesses as in the US and so on.
Source: https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2...