>(1) if you’re vaccinated, common sense suggests you’d be more likely to go back to normal as compared to pre-vax (increasing chances of getting covid)
This statement may be true. But it's not obvious to me. You could also argue that many people who got fully vaxed and even boosters where available are also more cautious in general, other things being equal. Again, not arguing this statement is untrue but a lot of people are still being cautious in various ways and I'm pretty sure there's a lot of overlap between that group and those who got vaccines early on.