> A correlation between change size and review quality is acknowledged by Google and developers are strongly encouraged to make small, incremental changes
Heard though about wanting to maintain context within a stack. I think the best balance is tooling that both lets you create a stack of small changes, while also seeing each change in the broader context (forest).
The benefit of breaking out PRs instead of commits, is that each small change gets to pass review and CI atomically. I like your strategy of gating commit pushes until the first is reviewed, but I think the dream is to decouple those processes :)