This is the standard asceticism routine that every human religion in history followed. (And follows.)
I'll trust the weight of centuries of experience over some random internet source.
This is the standard asceticism routine that every human religion in history followed. (And follows.)
I'll trust the weight of centuries of experience over some random internet source.
Why?
Shouldn't any such practice / experience be based on results, ideally well controlled, rather than just something people did or do?
There's any number of things people in my old neck of the woods did for hundreds of years that I'm very happy to have escaped the heck away from :-)
But my comment was not even about reproducibility, though that is important, but another fundamental question: What is the goal?
Yes, many people over hundreds of years have behaved a certain way. But putting aside burden of evidence/reproducibility, whether I want to behave a certain way / same way, to me, hinges on a) What's my goal and b) Have those people obtained that goal?
Random trivial examples: IF my goal is to have a happy family life with a partner and bunch of kids; following people who practiced isolation and asceticism will probably not satisfy that goal, no matter how many of them did it over however many hundreds of years. Insert any number of other trivial or complex goals (leading people, developing a rich and meaningful social life, sending a rocket to the moon, experiencing a lot of different experiences, travelling, seeing the world - whatever ). I find the whole "lots of people did this, so I'll trust their experience" pretty meaningless without stating "what is your goal? What do you consider good? What do you desire?" and then "did those people reach that goal? And what are the aspects of their life that contributed to it?"
(FWIW, I find that is frequently the case on internet forums; with my friends, explicitly or implicitly I understand their perspective/context/goals, so we can discuss politics or history or morals knowing each others assumptions or goals. On the internet, a LOOOOT of discussion is pretty circular because nobody stated their goals; so how can we discuss whether something is good/productive/leading to desired state; or bad/counter-productive/leading to negative state; etc. But that's a much broader concern than what we have here:).
My comment was solely to poke a hole in the idea that only things that can be reproduced in double blind studies are truth.
When reality, our modern science is many times far from reality, and getting further each day. (See: reproducibility crisis)
Even “scientific proof” should have a healthy dose of skepticism, and “nothing but anecdotal evidence” should be considered more thoroughly.
The pitfalls of outsourcing critical thinking to double blind studies is the thrust of my point.
I agree, though I will selfishly bring it up to my own point of defining goals/scopes/mandates a priori :)
If my partner and I are discussing what's the best colour for the kitchen, double-blinded studies are of limited help and Truth is ephemeral and subjective :).
If we are discussing mathematical theorems, double-blinded study may be an irrelevant construct.
For some social or psychological areas, double-blinded study may be helpful but difficult or impossible to ethically configure, repeatably conduct, meaningfully interpret, and clean up of confounding variables etc.
And for yet other areas, it's the best tool we have to help confirm at a workable, useful, predictive model.
That is to say that there are meaningful answers to that question that go either way. Not to mention Tarski's undefinability theorem.
There are human superpowers, like increasing or decreasing your core temperature, consciously resisting infections, deliberately triggering the placebo effect, feats of memory, endurance, or cognition. Science is making inroads to the mechanics of many of these feats.
Asceticism seems like a clear cut system for improving cognition by letting the baselines of dopaminergic activity settle down. I can see the potential for negative effects of overstimulation, but where there's atrope, there's usually a kernel of truth to be found. Intellectuals and scholars are known to retreat from the world to silence and study for extended periods. Removing external stimulation is about as obvious as it gets when you want to focus on something. However, sensory deprivation- the extreme end of the axis - is known to have extremely negative effects, sometimes within a couple days. There's clearly a minimum threshold of stimulation needed to retain your sanity.
Running studies on cognitive performance through the use of deprivation tanks, silent retreats, minimal stimulation lifestyles, and other methodologies would be interesting. If a once weekly tank session provides as much benefit as daily silent retreats, or a month of living in isolation, or something like that, it would give people reasons to improve their well-being. My own suspicion is that infrequent tank use is probably as beneficial as more rigorous asceticism, but that's just opinion.
With the doors open to psychedelics research, I'd love to see the comparative results from ascetic practice with and without psychedelics over 6 month periods.
the random internet source in this case happens to be harvard medical laying out basic facts about how dopamine works in the human brain and why you can't actually 'fast' it.
General point being, if you weigh "weights of centuries" higher than modern expertise, you would still believe that night air is dangerous and your four humors are out of balance instead of believing in germs. The chance that anyone who posts on HN actually treats their illnesses with ancient religious practice is, I'd wager, very low. And that tells you all there is to it.
This, to my mind, is a perfect example of people getting carried away. It is definitely the case that dopamine signalling occurs in the retina, but the connection between that and any sort of higher-level “affective” phenomenon seems pretty tenuous.
(Ok, granted, "worth" of civilization might be debatable.)