To me, it seems these changes are oriented towards helping everyone succeed in STEM, even those who don’t think they’re math people. Which, again, is less to do with their actual abilities and much more to do with their mental dialogue.
This makes a ton of sense. Basically any skill or habit you might want to develop can be easily thwarted if you’re struggling mentally with discipline, focus, self-image, etc. In my opinion, the “mental game” is crucial to nearly everything and doesn’t get enough focus. (Think of how in sports, a bad mental game can easily loose you the physical game even if you’re an incredible athlete.)
I doubt these educational changes would ever have much of an impact on bonafide geniuses, because they are operating in an entirely different context.
It should be both.
Of all the things to evaluate the policy on, this is a real poor proxy as whether there are gifted people or not usually has little bearing on the overall health of math education across a very highly populated state.
I never disagreed with whether they exist or not. I just don't see why this is such a sore point for people. I can virtually guarantee that the existing education system in CA didn't really benefit the gifted folks either. If I were setting up the program for a whole state, whether it will be good for a Jacobi/Euler/Gauss is totally irrelevant. We're not going to make people who show up once every 50-100 years be a major factor in educating millions of people.
Your reply is that we shouldn't design a state-wide math program for extreme outliers. But no one said we should! We only said that we should design a math program that acknowledges a diversity in innate math ability (as proven by the existence of extreme outliers, and the many, many less extreme outliers).