Edit: General response to the responses. I am not advocating for Zillow to be a source of truth, I was responding to the parent comment of my post and their mention of Zillow. What I am saying is that we are not limited to using methodologies of the past, there are vast datasets and modern data collection methods available to us now that can be used.
None of that relates the question of whether Zillow, on overage, correctly predicts how much the market, in the aggregate, has moved.
I think you're confusing separate issues because they both merge into a narrative of "zillow bad".
Zillow, Redfin, etc list at prices that may be inflated, but they always list the purchased pricing as far back as they can and raise estimate to last sale if higher.