If this is true - whether because the courts don't enforce the "spirit" of the original law or for some other reason - why can't all companies just use Section 230 like the tech "platforms"? I mean CNN, Fox, NYTimes, etc. have big digital footprints, hire teams of engineers, publish "user-generated" content (i.e. comment sections), host videos, etc. Why are they subject to libel and defamation lawsuits, but Google, FB, etc. get to hide behind section 230?
Why did only CNN, MSNBC, etc. get publicly humiliated by the Covington kid's lawyers when partisan "moderators" at Google and Facebook essentially posted the exact same libelous content (either directly or by just censoring / amplifying the posts of others)? Why have both Fox news (e.g. Tucker Carlson) and MSNBC (Rachel Maddow) had to spend millions defending themselves recently from defamation lawsuits, when Zuckerburg or Sundar Pichai could essentially make the EXACT same claims they did on their "platforms", yet be protected by this vague Section 230 shield?
It seems like the law has become a joke, where you're basically guaranteed protection if you're head-quartered in California and considered a "tech company," while older established companies have to play by a completely different set of rules, even if their business models are exactly the same (selling ads and narratives, propaganda dissemination, etc.)