I'm getting real tired of hearing these sob stories about not being able to pay for rent and food and being saddled with a lifetime of debt because you make very poor decisions
I'm getting real tired of hearing these sob stories about not being able to pay for rent and food and being saddled with a lifetime of debt because you make very poor decisions
We need to stop literally underwriting (as taxpayers) bad decisions. And private banks that do underwrite such decisions need to face the possibility of bankruptcy in some form (maybe not quick and easy bankruptcy after 2 years, but something).
Who is responsible for drinking the poison?
I agree that we don't prepare high school kids for real life. We're too busy focusing on their feelings and building a generation of weak minded fools that will never be fully functional adults.
I also agree that we need government out of the edu loan business. It is a poison pill and just enriches the self-serving class that operates these schools.
The greatest mistake was allowing them to lobby and sell the American people the BS that a college degree is required to live a good life. There are endless examples of that not being the case.
* All your friends are leaving to amazing places. If you don't go you'll be left behind.
* Going to college is a high class move. Even if you're poor, people will still probably think you are high class if you sign up.
* Everyone says you make more money.
* People won't hire you unless you have a degree.
* If you sign here, you get awesome friends, the best dating opportunities possible on Earth, and we'll show you your true path in life.
* Nobody will ever criticize this decision even if it's foolish. No matter how foolish, the worst case scenario still shields you from any consequences for five years.
* Five years is a long time. Maybe you'll marry someone with money that you meet here. And politicians keep talking about free college, so maybe you won't have to pay it back.
An 18 year old would have to be really mature and self-confident not to sign up. Maybe a wise 18 year old would choose a cheap college and a good major, but very few will resist it entirely.
People are more thirsty than ever for college.
This is one of the things I got most wrong about the Pandemic (the other being they wouldn't dare attempt a third lockdown).
[edit] I guess also the explosion of the chinese upper middle class should also be a big factor.
While I agree, there is a clear benefit to the student, and to society (through the student's productivity), in learning from the best teachers with better resources, and in a community of the most brilliant people (which tend to become very expensive). I want public health professionals that come up with brilliant solutions to our problems. Anyone in any profession I think would choose that avenue of skill acquisition over the discount option. People in finance go to NY, people in IT go to SV, etc., for good reasons.
That said, it is a matter of degree. NYU seems to be near one pole of extra cost. If you are in California, for example, there are at least two public universities that are considered better than NYU.
That advice doesn’t seem to have percolated through to the hoi polloi yet though.
(And the bigger questionn: people who aren't on HN are hoi polloi? Wow. What does that make us? And it's so easy to get an HN account ...)
Sounds like a very low ROI degree.
If you're interested in getting an advanced education in the healthcare field, you might as well either get an MD (to make the advanced degree worth it) or go to a less expensive city and become a PA, DPT, or OT at a public university.
Out of all of the options in healthcare, MPH at NYU seems like the most excessive waste of money.
Many graduates from the top MPH programs go onto leadership and management positions - for these programs, my experience is that there is a significant focus on the leadership aspect layered with specialist knowledge in policy, epidemiology, biostatistics, health care administration, etc. Many MPH programs will offer subspecialties like that - so you get, for example, an MPH in biostatistics or epi rather than a generic MPH without a focus.
Pay can vary greatly. Some MPH graduates will work in non-profits and others will wind-up running clinical trials at big pharma. You can imagine the kind of salary range those very different job types cover.
I would be extremely cautious about making a ROI judgement of the MPH. I know MPH grads who have worked as direct advisors to US senators, MPH grads who write biostats software, and MPH grads who help run rape crisis centers in underserved communities. There are also combined programs for MD/MPH linking up a school of medicine at a university with its MPH program. Those grads are often looking to lead research efforts or county-level health departments.
More generally speaking, I think you aren't wrong about NYU being an "excessive waste of money" but I don't think that has much to do with the degree in question. I have met too many successful people with "low ROI" degrees just in the software industry to feel confident about judging these programs in general. Which, of course, is very different than saying it is a good idea to rack up $157,000 in debt (like the student FTA) for any program from any school.