Likewise “heirs” is a misnomer. Most millionaires in the US did not inherit their wealth, they accumulated it.
Marxism is religious bunk.
Likewise “heirs” is a misnomer. Most millionaires in the US did not inherit their wealth, they accumulated it.
Marxism is religious bunk.
Marxism happens to be correct as a science, even if its conclusions are against your own class interests. Possibly the most obvious example is the tendency of the rate of profit to fall.
> Possibly the most obvious example is the tendency of the rate of profit to fall.
So your evidence of the validity of Marxism is... a 50-50 shot? Even in the replication crisis, science at least demands no more than 5% chance for hypotheses to come true by random luck.
The rate of profit has a historical tendency to fall, as companies are incentivised to produce cheaper by automating. This reduces the proportion of costs attributed to labour, which means either reducing wages or reducing profits. Since workers will resist being paid less than they can survive on, profits end up falling over time.
The rate of profit does get reset by destruction of capital (like wars), just like the labour theory of value suggests. This can be seen historically, using data collected by mainstream economists. You can find such graphs in most economics textbooks. Here's some more on the topic https://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2020/07/25/a-world-ra...
Yes, of course in the course of competition, in mature industries profit will reduce to the cost of capital; although automation (as a productivity improvement) will delay this process, not accelerate it. But as industries mature, others arise through innovation.
Simply drawing a trend line on a graph (and it's not clear what the graph is displaying) and exclaiming that it fits theory is nowhere near enough to evidence a hypothesis, especially when the counter-trends are contrary to theory. What destruction of capital occurred in the early '80s?
The overall global rate of profit has been steadily falling since the beginning of capitalism; this is not disputed by bourgeois economists. Destroying capital is one way to reset it, which did happen in the 80s as well through war and closing of “old” industries. Along with forced privatisations, which opened up more of the economy to commodity production for profit. And along with deregulation and violent suppression of labour movements, to reduce the price of labour. Neoliberalism is what temporarily raised the rate of profit in the 80s.
There is certainly no consensus that the global rate of return is in long-term decline, and much evidence to the contrary, particularly over the recent decades when econometric data has become sufficient to measure it. And anyway, even if there were a secular trend, Marxian economics could not explain it because that theory is dependent on Marx's law of value, which is entirely contradicted by evidence.
TIL only capitalists can invent products.