Really everyone is complaining. It is not affordable. So even persons with high income like doctors or engineers are struggeling. So often you just hear, the only chance is to inherit it...
Really everyone is complaining. It is not affordable. So even persons with high income like doctors or engineers are struggeling. So often you just hear, the only chance is to inherit it...
I'd note that Doctors and Engineers don't really get high salaries compared to the US though. Europe is all about landlordism and inheritance.
The main problem in my opinion regarding Germany is that it becomes really hard to accumulate wealth, you have high taxes, real estate prices are high and the consumer prices are rising. So inheritance plays a really big role.
That's by design, isn't it? You're not really supposed to build up private wealth, you're supposed to fund social security systems and rely on them when in trouble.
I remember some high-ranking politician (I believe SPD, but my memory is weak) said in regards to Germany's low personal wealth that in Germany your wealth is having a social system you can rely on (and thus you don't need to have personal wealth).
No developed country serves working people. And it isn’t made to serve the aristocracy, either. Businesses and business interests rule over all. That much the US and the apparent monolith of Europe has in common, at least.
The only difference is that professionals—those with “careers”—are probably paid less in Europe in general compared to their peers in the US. Which is probably the reason why there is so much seething on HN about how Europe is oppressing people—Europe (or at least Western/Northern Europe) is relatively egalitarian overall, but tech nerds aren’t paid five times as much as their plumber, which is a real injustice.
Well, that's something new for me. On the opposite, I see many people complain about (1) medical care costs in the USA, and how the system is designed in a wrong way - in Europe, you can either pay (much less than in the USA) or get healthcare for free, (2) no guaranteed PTO - in Europe, you have guaranteed 26 days + public holidays, (3) extremely high cost of higher education (in most of Europe is free/quite cheap), (4) related to that, student debt getting out of control (this is showing up often on HN), (5) inhuman approach to parental leave - you often need to go back to your factory a few weeks after giving birth to your baby! FB boasts of 4 months - how generous of them! In many European countries you get a year. Moreover, there are laws giving similar rights to fathers.
Weeks ? Not in America!
>A day after giving birth, I was asked back to work. America needs paid family leave
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/dec/27/americ...
I posted that article the other day, didn't get as much traction as the DoorDash delivery story.
You very much do have a nightmare for poor people in America, you can do everything right and stub your toe, and end up $30,000 in medical debt overnight. People die all the time just because they can't afford healthcare. It can actually be cheaper, assuming you can manage getting on a plane and all that to fly to London, and treat your stub toe there versus treating it here. It's absolutely ridiculous what we put working people through in America.
Mental health care is also extremely expensive, for example, your concerned about your spending habits. Your looking to therapy, but then you realize a therapist will cost upwards of $1,600 a month.
Or maybe you lose your job and can no longer afford to pay $3,000 a month for various psychiatric medicines. It's as if we're all living in a demented Dickinson's novel, you get fired on Monday, your daughter loses her health insurance Tuesday, and your daughter may die since she ends up skipping essential medical care.
Of course we have half-assed stop gaps, for example, if after losing your job you have a spare $1,500 a month you can keep your employee health insurance. Cobra as it's called is everything wrong with America.
Even with a job, it's cheaper for me to pay out of pocket for health care. I have this luxury since I know Pythons, but when I was younger I just didn't go to the doctor. This caused all types of strange issues which I'm still working on.
It's a function of how incredibly high wealth disparity is. Go to the richest part of town in any big city sometime in the evening. >70% (often more than 90%) of the lights are off, because nobody is home in these multimillion $ homes, because they are 2nd, 3rd or 4th home. So the people who can afford houses that >90% of the people can never afford, can buy many of these without blinking an eye.
The expected market price of a home in terms of rent should be “what you can afford”, and with that argument the expected purchase price would be the number that makes the capital cost of a loan the same as the rent (minus some maintenance and other factors).
If interest rates are tiny then the expected mortgage for a house will be huge. Especially if there are no regulations requiring the length of mortgages.
is renting not an option? Why is only purchasing counted?
So with the current high housing asset prices and low rental prices, purchasing a house doesn't make financial sense.
the mortgage is not 100% comparable to the rent, since not 100% of the mortgage is unrecoverable cost, unlike rent.
Some percentage of the mortgage payment is the principle payment. If you subtract this principle payment, and add in the cost of capital for the mortgage (which is the opportunity cost of the initial deposit), you can then compare the cost of mortgage with rent.
In most cases, rent should be cheaper (but of course, not always).
A nice rule of thumb is to have a 5% rule - if you can rent annually for less than 5% of the cost of the property, you'd be ahead financially.
In many cities where buy prices are high the renter will end up with a higher net worth in the end.
The main thing that makes renting a worse deal in many jurisdictions are the tax subsidies towards home ownership and taxation of rentals, otherwise in a working market it's a little rentiers profit and a lot of risk pricing / speculation.
Generally renting may take a smaller slice of your cash flow and allow you to invest the difference which will decide which will affect which scenario will come out $$ wise ahead in the endgame.
Look at London or Barcelona for example. Landlords in these cities aren’t hoping to come anywhere near covering their mortgages with rent payments, they are hoping to profit from real estate appreciation.
This is really basic economics, it’s incredible to see people railing against this on HN. Even the home-ownership obsessed US is full of cities where it’s a vastly better financial decision to rent instead of buying.
Most landlords here are betting on property values continuing to grow, they’ll never turn a profit on rents.