While certainly more plausible than 9/11 conspiracy theories, the lab-leak proponents have the same tendency to put forth several mutually incompatible theories, while believing each has a strong amount of evidence for it.
While certainly more plausible than 9/11 conspiracy theories, the lab-leak proponents have the same tendency to put forth several mutually incompatible theories, while believing each has a strong amount of evidence for it.
“The results, which are not peer reviewed, have been posted on the preprint server Research Square.”
Sounds like very lazy “journalism” to me.
And the study on Laos bats is clearly undergoing peer-review: https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-871965/v1
https://www.bmartin.cc/dissent/documents/AIDS/River/Prospect...
I think it's important to understand the writer's past history on an analogous subject, as it points to his motivations. I think letting you know he also previously argued about the benefits of global warming "nourishing the oceans", https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/now-heres-the-good-news-o... , points to the type of arguments this person likes to make.
I agree the stuff about his failed bank is irrelevant.
Also, his coauthor on the current book has impeccable credentials as perhaps the leading honest broker in the field, so these comments feel a bit like looking for a weak flank to attack.
The article you link is a very well written boon review which summarizes the arguments of the book. Ridley's review concludes that the theory that aids was transferred to humans through large-scale experimental vaccinations with vaccines made out of chimp liver is a theory worth further investigation.
This is GOOD SCIENCE. You analyze data and put forward theory. I can't speak to the merits of the theory or the book being reviewed, but why would it discredit Ridley if he reads and reviews critical books and is open to exploring alternative theories?
For example, I think it is extremely relevant and valid to point out Daszek's clear conflict of interest when he put out his original letter.
In this case, the fact that the writer has promoted other theories (importantly, theories analogous to the one under discussion) I consider completely crackpot certainly makes me look at the data here with a more skeptical eye.
More importantly, there are plenty of other researchers who I consider much more credible who have raised loud alarms about the chance of a lab leak (e.g. Zeynep Tufekci's excellent analysis here, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/25/opinion/coronavirus-lab.h... ). The fact that I can look at one piece of writing with a more critical eye based on the author's history of insincerity does not mean I discount more credible researchers making similar arguments.
How would a disease from a bat from Laos make it to Wuhan? It still could be from the WIV!
- Opening the records about which viruses the WIV was storing. It's not a mystery — labs track that kind of thing! But China refused to release any data about which viruses the WIV stored or modified.
- Finding a clear chain of infection between a natural source and the outbreak in Wuhan
- Finding clear evidence that there was a small outbreak which later spread to Wuhan
Nobody has managed any of those.
I would invite you to think about that a little longer.
1. It is, in principle, good thinking to keep multiple competing hypotheses in mind, and allow each new piece of information you get to adjust your level of credence in each one, rather than picking one to Believe and Disbelieving all the others.
2. It is, in practice, a common sort of bad thinking to treat a bundle of mutually incompatible theories as a single thing, and to handwavily treat any bit of information that supports any of them as supporting the whole bundle, even when what the information actually does is to support some bits and undermine others.
And also
3. It is also a common sort of bad thinking to adjust one's beliefs not on the basis of looking concretely at how likely a new piece of information is if each of your multiple competing hypotheses is true, but on the basis of vague notions of what feels as if it supports what.
I take the New Republic review to be mostly accusing Chan & Ridley of doing 2 and 3 in the guise of 1. I haven't read their book and can't tell how fair that accusation is.
Similarly, the following are both true.
1'. It is, in principle, good thinking to adjust the hypotheses you're considering in the light of new evidence, which may promote new hypotheses or new variants of old hypotheses to consideration.
2'. It is, in practice, a common sort of bad thinking to respond to criticism of your beliefs by moving the goalposts: you say A1, someone says "but P!", you adjust to A2 which is compatible with P, someone says "but Q!", you adjust to A3 which is compatible with Q, and at that point you don't check whether it's also compatible with P, so you confuse "at each step I had a version of my beliefs that was nicely compatible with the evidence presented to me" with "there is a version of my beliefs that is simultaneously compatible with all the evidence".
And also
3'. Adjusting your hypotheses in the light of new evidence can lead to problems akin to overfitting in machine learning, where you find something that fits very nicely with the specific bits of evidence you looked at but not with the other evidence that's out there, because you optimized it to fit as well as possible with those specific bits of evidence.
I take the New Republic review to be accusing Chan & Ridley of doing 2' and 3' in the guise of 1'. Again, since I haven't read their book it's not clear how fair the accusation is.
What I would like to see is something that lays out a few specific hypotheses (SARS-CoV-2 deliberately engineered with malicious purposes; SARS-CoV-2 deliberately engineered for study with the goal of understanding/preventing/mitigating future pandemics; SARS-CoV-2 found naturally in bats or something but brought into contact with humans via the WIV; SARS-CoV-2 found naturally in bats or something and brought into contact with humans via the Wuhan wet market; maybe a couple more) and then goes through the available evidence trying to assess what each piece of evidence does to each hypothesis, noting where better versions of the hypotheses are suggested by the evidence and then either assessing those better versions against other evidence or just presenting them as "suggested by the available evidence but now in need of further verification or refutation as new evidence comes in".
It doesn't seem to me, from either the Aaronson review or the NR review, as if the Chan & Ridley book does anything much like that. (To a good approximation, no one ever does anything much like that, and it's a pity.)