We tend to forget that children and young minds live on the internet now and they will be influenced by Reddit and Twitter posts. It's a real problem that I think we make for a more radical younger generation.
Not only there; this line of reasoning is seeping into mainstream media like the New York Times or the Guardian, who really should know better. This is really disturbing, as progressives really should fight for things like the right to blasphemy, the freedom to caricature and the complete secularisation of the law instead of fighting for religious loopholes on behalf of fundamentalist theocrats.
That behaviour, in the wake of the Charlie people killed for a couple of drawings, is as progressive as “she had it coming” blame-the-victim Bible thumpers.
It is, of course, a total coincidence that most muslims are brown.
Except of course it isn’t. Caricatures poking fun at various religions are common, have been for quite a while, and people complain about them regularly. Yet we’ve somehow accepted that we can make fun of a big guy with a beard. Somehow nobody has been killed over the Life of Brian.
There are a couple of fundamental human rights to which everyone is entitled. These include freedom of conscience, the right to live in peace, and freedom of expression. Religion is fine as long as it does not interfere with the rights of other people, which includes the right to laugh at beliefs. Humans have rights, ideas don’t.
On the other hand, nobody has a right not to be upset, and certainly not to kill people and plant bombs over it. It really should be a no brainer for anyone supposed to be supportive of any kind of enlightenment values.
This ”they should not do it, but” is just as bad as “I am not racist, but”. That we are arguing whether people have a moral right to violence where the rule of law prevails, over something as trivial as hurt feelings, is absolutely disgusting.
Try to substitute “Islam” for any philosophy or belief to see how patently absurd that is. Republicans are upset when you tell them Biden won. Should we censure that from public discourse?
Oh come on, his statement is clearly not just about caricatures, but about a general trend, not only in french society, which is especially toxic towards religious people, but especially to Muslims. The evidence is abundant and anyone who has not an axe to grind, like yourself, will have no issue in acknowledging these facts.
> There are a couple of fundamental human rights to which everyone is entitled.
Really, is that so? Can you provide scientific evidence for this or do we have to take you word for it? Can we discover those 'fundamental human rights' under the microscope or are 'enlightened' individuals going to dictate to others what are and aren't 'fundamental human rights'?
> On the other hand, nobody has a right not to be upset
Rights are just arbitrary inventions of the human mind so any society has the power to implement whatever rights they like. Not that I am in favour of that, just trying to make it clear that those platitudes you acquired in your circles are farcical. Apropos farcical, there are enough cases which are evidence that people apparently are entitled to be upset, because whenever powerful individuals in french society are mocked or ridiculed the consequences are very different e.g. Charlie Hebdo fired Maurice Sinet (who had been drawing political cartoons since the 50s!) for mocking Sarkozy's son.
Again I expect no concession from you whatsoever, you clearly have a big axe to grind, just putting this out there as a reference for neutral observers.
want he fired on suspicion of antisemitism? He won a unlawful termination suit so why do the newspapers actions (versus the courts) represent western values?
It's obvious to me jewish a special case, rightly it wrongly, because of WW2.
Besides, it’s not like the country has a way of changing its laws anyway.
There are ethical frameworks, secular moral frameworks, and religious moral frameworks. In my observation people love moral frameworks, because moral frameworks have the output of righteousness. They're useful for hegemony, they provide some sense of justice through outcasting, and they allow people to see themselves compared to others. They're also quite dynamic and can have modified interpretation by an individual.
Ethical frameworks are a little less fulfilling because their intended outcome is fairness. Users may have to sacrifice their own perspectives for the ethical framework to remain fair.
The issue is unregulated moral communities. We, as humans, think freedom to moral communities, whether they be religious or secular, is the right thing to do because of generations of religious warring. There are some amount of moral community people that will never switch to an ethical framework because of that strive for righteousness. While it'd probably be healthier to get away from morals altogether, the mean time would be filled with a lot of strife, imo, where righteous people would act on their righteousness.
Treating millions of jews as a 'monolithic' group in order to discriminate against them was the beginning of something very disturbing, something which you probably missed in history class.