What's scary is when a developer becomes convinced that a conspiracy has been concocted to brigade and attack their project. I was accused of being an agent of the other side, as were a number of others. All of that happened within that thread. You need only scroll through.
After the lead developer's response, I investigated for myself and found GrapheneOS' own Matrix channels hotbeds of this same conspiratorial thinking. Regular purges were done to eliminate anyone remotely critical of the project. It got so bad that the member lists of both projects' Matrix channels were compared and anyone found to be a member of both sent a warning to pick a side or be permabanned.
That behavior inside a community is not healthy. I don't think that discourse is healthy.
I am all for technical, compassionate criticism of a project. One that allows or leaves a door open to further, good-faith, discussion. USA-RedDragon's critical analysis in this very thread [1] is a great example.
No one should use particularly high stakes as an excuse to treat other human beings poorly. Linus Torvalds, once infamous for this sort of behavior, realized it for himself and the rest of us can too.
These two projects would be so much stronger if they discussed technical disagreements without going nuclear. I hope that can be done someday but until then these arguments are best done outside Hacker News threads, which are encouraged to foster thoughtful and substantive discussions, not cater to delusory fantasies of paranoia.
IMO, the fact that your original comment here was flagged while RedDragon's was not should suggest what constitutes good-faith and healthy discussion.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28098495 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28095033
You are missing a lot of dead comments from that thread, one of which [1] even speaks to those dead comments accusing people of being in cahoots with an invented enemy. I'd say the most damning of comments preserved is [2] where the lead developer of GrapheneOS names Calyx's Nick as leading what amounts to a brigade of death threats against him personally.
Your citation is accusing the lead developer of GrapheneOS as acting in bad faith. While I agree they’re opinionated (based on this and other observations), I don’t believe they’ve ever acted in bad faith.
PS: for what it’s worth, I’ve supported Calyx namely for their services, whereas I support GrapheneOS as an Android replacement.
There is more interesting and useful info in the comment thread in your link than this page. You call it a flame war. I don't. They could have been a bit more "good faith" but it was extremely valuable and not very "flamey"
It's important to be highly critical of and precise when talking about security and privacy oriented projects since the stakes are particularly high. Any discussion around technical choices and their impact on security and/or privacy does not diminish the work of project developers or call into question their effort and abilities.