If you are interested in the topic a quick google will yeild lots of good articles. I found this list of elements useful to organize my thinking:
Rogue Like:
High-value factors
1. Random environment generation
2. Permadeath
3. Turn-based
4. Grid-based
5. Non-modal
6. Complexity
7. Resource management
8. Hack n slash
9. Exploration or discovery
Low-value factors
1. Single-player character
2. Monsters are similar to players
3. Tactical challenge
4. ASCII display
5. Dungeons
6. Numbers