So at this point it is not clear if this relation is an artifact of the simulation or there is a real dependency.
So at this point it is not clear if this relation is an artifact of the simulation or there is a real dependency.
Based on this clip from David Tong. Starts here and goes on a few minutes: https://youtu.be/zNVQfWC_evg?t=2714
> But in practice, the technique would have to first overcome a major weakness. The CAMELS collaboration cooks up its universes using two different recipes. A neural network trained on one of the recipes makes bad density guesses when given galaxies that were baked according to the other. The cross-prediction failure indicates that the neural network is finding solutions unique to the rules of each recipe
> The team spent half a year trying to understand how the neural network had gotten so wise. They checked to make sure the algorithm hadn’t just found some way to infer the density from the coding of the simulation rather than the galaxies themselves.